{"apiVersion":"v1","generatedAt":"2026-05-15T14:35:15.031Z","canonicalUrl":"https://eduaipolicy.org/universities/national-tsing-hua-university","license":"CC-BY-4.0","trackerMetadataLicense":"CC-BY-4.0","sourcePolicy":"Tracker metadata is open licensed. Official source documents, page text, PDFs, and other source materials retain their original rights and terms.","sourceRightsPolicy":"Tracker metadata is open licensed. Official source documents, page text, PDFs, and other source materials retain their original rights and terms.","limitations":["Policy analysis profiles are deterministic summaries of public tracker claims and are not final policy conclusions.","Policy Coverage Score measures breadth of public, source-backed coverage; it is not a policy quality score, strictness score, legal adequacy score, safety score, or institutional compliance score.","This tracker is not legal advice, not academic integrity advice, and not an official university statement unless a linked source is the university's own official page."],"citation":{"citationTitle":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU policy analysis profile","canonicalUrl":"https://eduaipolicy.org/universities/national-tsing-hua-university","publicJsonUrl":"https://eduaipolicy.org/api/public/v1/analysis/universities/national-tsing-hua-university.json","suggestedCitation":"University AI Policy Tracker. \"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU policy analysis profile.\" Version v1. https://eduaipolicy.org/universities/national-tsing-hua-university","sourceRightsPolicy":"Tracker metadata is open licensed. Official source documents, page text, PDFs, and other source materials retain their original rights and terms."},"data":{"schemaVersion":"uapt-policy-analysis-v1","apiVersion":"v1","entityType":"university","entitySlug":"national-tsing-hua-university","entityName":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU","canonicalUrl":"https://eduaipolicy.org/universities/national-tsing-hua-university","publicJsonUrl":"https://eduaipolicy.org/api/public/v1/analysis/universities/national-tsing-hua-university.json","generatedAt":"2026-05-15T00:00:00.000Z","basedOnClaimIds":["claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-ai-competence-plan","claim-nthu-ai-guidelines-announced","claim-nthu-assessment-guidance","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response","claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility"],"basedOnSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","https://nthu-en.site.nthu.edu.tw/p/404-1003-249686.php"],"sourceLanguages":["en","zh-Hant"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.783,"coverageScore":{"score":75,"maxScore":100,"label":"broad_public_coverage","components":[{"key":"policy_presence","label":"Central AI policy or guidance source exists","points":15,"maxPoints":15,"status":"unclear","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-ai-guidelines-announced","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"academic_integrity","label":"Academic integrity guidance","points":15,"maxPoints":15,"status":"required","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"ai_disclosure","label":"AI disclosure guidance","points":15,"maxPoints":15,"status":"required","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"coursework","label":"Coursework guidance","points":10,"maxPoints":10,"status":"restricted","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-ai-competence-plan"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"exams","label":"Exam or assessment guidance","points":10,"maxPoints":10,"status":"restricted","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-assessment-guidance"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"privacy_data_entry","label":"Privacy or data-entry guidance","points":0,"maxPoints":15,"status":"not_mentioned","evidenceClaimIds":[],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"approved_tools","label":"Approved tools, procurement, or licensed tools","points":0,"maxPoints":10,"status":"not_mentioned","evidenceClaimIds":[],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"},{"key":"teaching_guidance","label":"Teaching or research guidance","points":10,"maxPoints":10,"status":"recommended","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-assessment-guidance"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate"}],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","limitations":["Policy Coverage Score measures breadth of public, source-backed coverage; it is not a policy quality score.","This tracker is not legal advice, not academic integrity advice, and not an official university statement unless a linked source is the university's own official page."]},"dimensions":[{"key":"policy_presence","label":"Policy presence","status":"unclear","normalizedValue":"announced_ai_education_guidelines_2023_05_01","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 2 source-backed public claims for policy presence; deterministic analysis status: unclear.","explanation":"Whether the public record contains official AI policy or guidance sources. This unclear status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 2 supporting public claims. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-ai-guidelines-announced","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://nthu-en.site.nthu.edu.tw/p/404-1003-249686.php"],"sourceLanguages":["en"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.791,"evidenceCount":2,"sourceCount":2,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-guidelines-announced","sourceUrl":"https://nthu-en.site.nthu.edu.tw/p/404-1003-249686.php","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"In response to the advent of generative artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot ChatGPT, National Tsing Hua University (NTHU) in Taiwan announced on May 1st the Guidelines for Collaboration, Co-learning, and Cultivation of Artificial Intelligence Competencies in University Education.","sourceSnapshotHash":"59c18a868db00a73ad777aae8c7d1cb8b67715ccfdb2beffab694effc0952209","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"Faculty members are encouraged to specify course logistics and policies regarding AIGC using one of the following four options: 1. Unrestricted use with no disclosure required 2. Conditionally open; please specify how to utilize generative AI in course output 3. Prohibited use; please specify relevant monitoring mechanisms 4. Not applicable","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"ai_disclosure","label":"AI disclosure","status":"required","normalizedValue":"transparency_responsibility_course_rules_disclosure","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 4 source-backed public claims for ai disclosure; deterministic analysis status: required.","explanation":"Whether public guidance addresses disclosure, acknowledgement, citation, or declaration of AI use. This required status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 4 supporting public claims. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf"],"sourceLanguages":["en","zh-Hant"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.778,"evidenceCount":4,"sourceCount":2,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"我們建議本校師生在教育場域中使用各種人工智慧(artificial intelligence，以下簡稱AI，不限於生成式人工智能)產品時應抱持透明與負責的態度：透明：教師應明確指出課程對於使用AI的規範，學生與教師使用AI時應誠實揭露。負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"教師教學 R 校方尊重教師對於課程使用 AI 工具的策略，教師應於課程大綱中敘明學生 使用 AI 的規則，尤其是正確引註 AI 並揭露使用的歷程。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"Faculty members are encouraged to specify course logistics and policies regarding AIGC using one of the following four options: 1. Unrestricted use with no disclosure required 2. Conditionally open; please specify how to utilize generative AI in course output 3. Prohibited use; please specify relevant monitoring mechanisms 4. Not applicable","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"If usage is discovered without proper disclosure, instructors, the institution, or relevant units have the right to reevaluate the assignment or report or withhold scores.","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"coursework","label":"Coursework","status":"restricted","normalizedValue":"transparency_responsibility_course_rules_disclosure","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 5 source-backed public claims for coursework; deterministic analysis status: restricted.","explanation":"Whether public guidance addresses coursework, assignments, syllabi, papers, homework, or submitted work. This restricted status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 5 supporting public claims. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-ai-competence-plan"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf"],"sourceLanguages":["en","zh-Hant"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.779,"evidenceCount":5,"sourceCount":2,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"我們建議本校師生在教育場域中使用各種人工智慧(artificial intelligence，以下簡稱AI，不限於生成式人工智能)產品時應抱持透明與負責的態度：透明：教師應明確指出課程對於使用AI的規範，學生與教師使用AI時應誠實揭露。負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"教師教學 R 校方尊重教師對於課程使用 AI 工具的策略，教師應於課程大綱中敘明學生 使用 AI 的規則，尤其是正確引註 AI 並揭露使用的歷程。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"Faculty members are encouraged to specify course logistics and policies regarding AIGC using one of the following four options: 1. Unrestricted use with no disclosure required 2. Conditionally open; please specify how to utilize generative AI in course output 3. Prohibited use; please specify relevant monitoring mechanisms 4. Not applicable","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。使用時應具備檢核其正確性的判讀能力，並對自己產生的內容負責。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-competence-plan","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"AI 素養不僅是關涉撰寫程式的能力... 本校規劃培養學生 AI 素養：統整正式（課程、研究）與非正式的學習（社團、活動、競賽、實習）... 提供基礎及專業的 AI 課程... 將 AI 融入課程。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"exams","label":"Exams","status":"restricted","normalizedValue":"transparency_responsibility_course_rules_disclosure","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 5 source-backed public claims for exams; deterministic analysis status: restricted.","explanation":"Whether public guidance addresses exams, tests, quizzes, or examination conditions. This restricted status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 5 supporting public claims. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-assessment-guidance"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf"],"sourceLanguages":["en","zh-Hant"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.78,"evidenceCount":5,"sourceCount":2,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"我們建議本校師生在教育場域中使用各種人工智慧(artificial intelligence，以下簡稱AI，不限於生成式人工智能)產品時應抱持透明與負責的態度：透明：教師應明確指出課程對於使用AI的規範，學生與教師使用AI時應誠實揭露。負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"教師教學 R 校方尊重教師對於課程使用 AI 工具的策略，教師應於課程大綱中敘明學生 使用 AI 的規則，尤其是正確引註 AI 並揭露使用的歷程。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"Faculty members are encouraged to specify course logistics and policies regarding AIGC using one of the following four options: 1. Unrestricted use with no disclosure required 2. Conditionally open; please specify how to utilize generative AI in course output 3. Prohibited use; please specify relevant monitoring mechanisms 4. Not applicable","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。使用時應具備檢核其正確性的判讀能力，並對自己產生的內容負責。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-assessment-guidance","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"學習評量（作業/報告） R 依據課程屬性，可同意使用 AI 協助答題，但建議以多元形式繳交作業... 學習評量（考試） R 出題方向建議以更多需要深層推理、創造力、分析... 批判的問題，而非單純引述規則性問題。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"privacy_data_entry","label":"Privacy and data entry","status":"not_mentioned","summary":"No source-backed public claim about privacy or data-entry restrictions is present in this profile.","explanation":"This is an absence-of-evidence marker for the current tracker profile, not proof that no such policy exists.","evidenceClaimIds":[],"evidenceSourceUrls":[],"sourceLanguages":[],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0,"evidenceCount":0,"sourceCount":0,"notMentionedReason":"The current public tracker record does not contain claim evidence about personal, confidential, sensitive, regulated, or student data entry into AI tools.","basis":[]},{"key":"academic_integrity","label":"Academic integrity","status":"required","normalizedValue":"instructors_state_ai_use_rules_citation_disclosure_in_syllabi","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 3 source-backed public claims for academic integrity; deterministic analysis status: required.","explanation":"Whether public guidance connects AI use to academic integrity, misconduct, dishonesty, plagiarism, or cheating rules. This required status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 3 supporting public claims. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf"],"sourceLanguages":["en","zh-Hant"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.771,"evidenceCount":3,"sourceCount":2,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"教師教學 R 校方尊重教師對於課程使用 AI 工具的策略，教師應於課程大綱中敘明學生 使用 AI 的規則，尤其是正確引註 AI 並揭露使用的歷程。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。使用時應具備檢核其正確性的判讀能力，並對自己產生的內容負責。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-undisclosed-use-response","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"If usage is discovered without proper disclosure, instructors, the institution, or relevant units have the right to reevaluate the assignment or report or withhold scores.","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"approved_tools","label":"Approved tools","status":"not_mentioned","summary":"No source-backed public claim identifying approved or licensed AI tools is present in this profile.","explanation":"This is an absence-of-evidence marker for the current tracker profile, not proof that no such policy exists.","evidenceClaimIds":[],"evidenceSourceUrls":[],"sourceLanguages":[],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0,"evidenceCount":0,"sourceCount":0,"notMentionedReason":"The current public tracker record does not contain claim evidence that identifies institutionally approved, licensed, procured, or enterprise AI tools.","basis":[]},{"key":"named_ai_services","label":"Named AI services","status":"unclear","normalizedValue":"announced_ai_education_guidelines_2023_05_01","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 1 source-backed public claim for named ai services; deterministic analysis status: unclear.","explanation":"Whether public guidance names AI services such as ChatGPT, Copilot, Claude, Gemini, Grammarly, or DeepSeek. This unclear status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 1 supporting public claim. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-ai-guidelines-announced"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://nthu-en.site.nthu.edu.tw/p/404-1003-249686.php"],"sourceLanguages":["en"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.799,"evidenceCount":1,"sourceCount":1,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-guidelines-announced","sourceUrl":"https://nthu-en.site.nthu.edu.tw/p/404-1003-249686.php","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"In response to the advent of generative artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot ChatGPT, National Tsing Hua University (NTHU) in Taiwan announced on May 1st the Guidelines for Collaboration, Co-learning, and Cultivation of Artificial Intelligence Competencies in University Education.","sourceSnapshotHash":"59c18a868db00a73ad777aae8c7d1cb8b67715ccfdb2beffab694effc0952209","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"teaching_guidance","label":"Teaching guidance","status":"recommended","normalizedValue":"transparency_responsibility_course_rules_disclosure","summary":"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU has 5 source-backed public claims for teaching guidance; deterministic analysis status: recommended.","explanation":"Whether public guidance addresses instructors, teaching, classroom policy, assessment design, or syllabus language. This recommended status was derived from claim type, normalized value, and keyword rules over 5 supporting public claims. Review the basis array before reusing this as a policy conclusion.","evidenceClaimIds":["claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","claim-nthu-assessment-guidance"],"evidenceSourceUrls":["https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf"],"sourceLanguages":["en","zh-Hant"],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0.78,"evidenceCount":5,"sourceCount":2,"basis":[{"claimId":"claim-nthu-transparency-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"我們建議本校師生在教育場域中使用各種人工智慧(artificial intelligence，以下簡稱AI，不限於生成式人工智能)產品時應抱持透明與負責的態度：透明：教師應明確指出課程對於使用AI的規範，學生與教師使用AI時應誠實揭露。負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-course-ai-rule-disclosure","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"教師教學 R 校方尊重教師對於課程使用 AI 工具的策略，教師應於課程大綱中敘明學生 使用 AI 的規則，尤其是正確引註 AI 並揭露使用的歷程。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-syllabus-aigc-options","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/0613IntegratingEthicalGuidelinesforGenerativeAIintoNTHUCourseSyllabi.pdf","sourceLanguage":"en","evidenceSnippet":"Faculty members are encouraged to specify course logistics and policies regarding AIGC using one of the following four options: 1. Unrestricted use with no disclosure required 2. Conditionally open; please specify how to utilize generative AI in course output 3. Prohibited use; please specify relevant monitoring mechanisms 4. Not applicable","sourceSnapshotHash":"e73a4f6c4cd5461bde8567dccfe8258d96fb64cd3325e3ffdeb527e3f9234533","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-ai-accuracy-responsibility","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"負責：教師與學生應理解AI僅能作為素材提供的來源之一。使用時應具備檢核其正確性的判讀能力，並對自己產生的內容負責。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"},{"claimId":"claim-nthu-assessment-guidance","sourceUrl":"https://ctld.site.nthu.edu.tw/var/file/217/1217/img/4991/712376723.pdf","sourceLanguage":"zh-Hant","evidenceSnippet":"學習評量（作業/報告） R 依據課程屬性，可同意使用 AI 協助答題，但建議以多元形式繳交作業... 學習評量（考試） R 出題方向建議以更多需要深層推理、創造力、分析... 批判的問題，而非單純引述規則性問題。","sourceSnapshotHash":"d4f103f6dbf81a1281e297c012fbaec93b378d540d3bfae2d470b08ce32916c6","reviewState":"agent_reviewed"}]},{"key":"research_guidance","label":"Research guidance","status":"not_mentioned","summary":"No source-backed public claim about research AI use is present in this profile.","explanation":"This is an absence-of-evidence marker for the current tracker profile, not proof that no such policy exists.","evidenceClaimIds":[],"evidenceSourceUrls":[],"sourceLanguages":[],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0,"evidenceCount":0,"sourceCount":0,"notMentionedReason":"The current public tracker record does not contain claim evidence about research use, publication ethics, research data, grants, or human-subjects compliance.","basis":[]},{"key":"security_procurement","label":"Security and procurement","status":"not_mentioned","summary":"No source-backed public claim about AI security review or procurement is present in this profile.","explanation":"This is an absence-of-evidence marker for the current tracker profile, not proof that no such policy exists.","evidenceClaimIds":[],"evidenceSourceUrls":[],"sourceLanguages":[],"reviewState":"machine_candidate","confidence":0,"evidenceCount":0,"sourceCount":0,"notMentionedReason":"The current public tracker record does not contain claim evidence about security review, procurement, vendor approval, risk assessment, authentication, SSO, or enterprise licensing.","basis":[]}],"limitations":["Policy analysis profiles are deterministic summaries of public tracker claims and are not final policy conclusions.","Policy Coverage Score measures breadth of public, source-backed coverage; it is not a policy quality score, strictness score, legal adequacy score, safety score, or institutional compliance score.","This tracker is not legal advice, not academic integrity advice, and not an official university statement unless a linked source is the university's own official page."],"suggestedCitation":"University AI Policy Tracker. \"National Tsing Hua University - NTHU policy analysis profile.\" Version v1. https://eduaipolicy.org/universities/national-tsing-hua-university"}}